Dead end?
My (guarded) optimism in the preliminary posting after Bush gave his "road map" speech on Palestinian-Israeli peace last Friday was way off target. In an analytical piece from Jerusalem, the New York Times' James Bennet, wrote why:
"Bush pleased Israelis and dismayed Palestinians by describing the draft proposal as open to amendment, saying on Friday, 'We will expect and welcome contributions from Israel and the Palestinians to this document that will advance true peace.'"
The thing is that the three other members of the so-called Quartet (the EU, the UN and Russia) consider the "road map", which is still in the draft proposal stage, as fixed, and insist it imposes immediate concessions on both parties.
One point of contention was Bush"s statement: "As progress is made toward peace, settlement activity in the occupied territories must end." What the EU, UN and Russia worry about is that Bush is demanding the appointment of a powerful prime minister and an end to violence from the Palestinians now, in exchange for eventual Israeli concessions on halting settlement construction.
Instead of a "parallel process of simultaneous concessions," a Western diplomat said, Bush is "using the vocabulary of sequentialism."
Meanwhile, Israel itself is said to have sought many changes in the document, including, if we are to believe Aluf Benn in Ha'aretz, the following:
* The Israeli document demands that the Palestinian state that will emerge in an agreement with Israel and will do so following direct negotiations between the two sides and not through dialogue and understandings as the road map states.
* Israel also rejects the demand of immediate removal of all illegal outposts set up in the territories during the government of Prime Minister Ariel Sharon. According to the Israeli version, the government will "enforce the law in relation to the outposts."
* For the first time, in this document, Israel delineates the terms under which it will agree to a freeze in settlement activity: "following a continuous and comprehensive security calm."
* Israel rejects the notion that the freeze will also include the natural growth of settlements.
* The document rejects a further withdrawal in the West Bank, according to the Oslo Accords, and the removal of settlements in order to grant territorial continuity to a Palestinian state - even during the stage of the temporary borders.
* The Israeli document says the future of the settlements will be determined only by a final agreement and therefore Israel is only willing to grant territorial continuity to the Palestinians only where "this is possible."
FREE MINDS FOR THE MIDDLE EAST
Tuesday, March 18, 2003
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Blog Archive
-
▼
2003
(309)
-
▼
March
(100)
- Too sanguine Matthias on this website disagrees wi...
- Khazraji watch roundup I've received mail from var...
- My friend Chibli Mallat has written this article f...
- Horrible thought Britain has just denied an earlie...
- Powell's comeback? Important article in the Washin...
- Screwed? Colin Powell launched a broadside against...
- Perle of wisdom You can find Richard Perle's respo...
- beirut calling got a nice mention from Ty Burr in ...
- Lebanon's Shiites and Iraq From Lebanon, one of th...
- Rummy the dummy? Currently making the headlines is...
- Grand alliance I have received the list of countri...
- A man threatened to blow himself up at a Beirut br...
- Here's my weekly comment for the Lebanon section o...
- Errr, Sorry The Labor government has apologized to...
- Father knew best Secretary of defense Donald Rumsf...
- Were two British soldiers brutally executed by the...
- Al-Jazeera has gotten a beating in the West, both ...
- Panoptical war Criticism of Al-Jazeera is legitima...
- Hubris tamed? For a newspaper that supported an Ir...
- News in that Richard Perle, the chairman of the De...
- This from The Scotsman, on the formation of an Ira...
- Here's a story from the New York Times suggesting ...
- Postwar Iraq? Al-Hayat will publish an interview t...
- With the sergeant This quote has made the email ro...
- Having (cautiously) posted a link to a Russian web...
- News on BBC radio that Turkey has sent members of ...
- From Beirut news of more antiwar demonstrations, w...
- Have just settled into my pew to read Condoleezza ...
- Is the U.S. invasion force in Iraq too small? Some...
- Thanks to an email list I belong to, I received th...
- The Bush administration is reporting (paragraphs a...
- Collateral damage from the bombing of Iraqi Televi...
- Readers might be interested in this English part o...
- In the latest news on the supposed uprising in Bas...
- Thief of Washington So the cat is out of the bag. ...
- According to CNN, British forces are reporting tha...
- The Baath regime’s efforts to co-opt Shiite religi...
- From the "God is on our side" files. An Iraqi mili...
- Real Turkeys While Americans continue to fulminate...
- Now is a good time to reflect on the fate of the I...
- Readers might be interested in my weekly review (m...
- My friend Joe Bahout (whose elegant ruminations we...
- William Saletan has written a concise piece on Ira...
- Given my continued interest in Gen. Nizar Khazraji...
- Where is Uday? A curiosity I haven't been able to ...
- Al-Jazeera has just shown footage taken from Iraqi...
- The Washington Post is reporting, in a very intere...
- Circular confirmation? Gen. Tommy Franks has been ...
- This Washington Post article suggests the U.S. is ...
- U.S. aircraft apparently fired at a Syrian bus Sun...
- Reports from a participant on a specialized email ...
- Today was apparently the moment of truth for Donal...
- Al-Jazeera has interviewed the commander of Iraq's...
- On its front page, the Lebanese left-wing daily Al...
- In its Saturday edition, the London-based daily Al...
- Al-Jazeera is showing footage from Iraqi televisio...
- Reports of antiwar demonstrations all over the wor...
- Just out of curiosity, why does the BBC say, when ...
- Iraq vice-president Taha Yassin Ramadan has appear...
- The Basra reversal. Being a television veteran of...
- One can feel the mood significantly changing in Le...
- Here in Beirut the mood remains calm. There have b...
- Euronews is quoting U.S. officials to the effect t...
- Eric Rouleau, a former French ambassador to Turkey...
- War crimes update. According to the London-based d...
- Clausewitz (and Powell) challenged. The Washington...
- Makiya watch You can read a new installment of Kan...
- From the "air power cannot do it alone" files, pol...
- For some reason I have taken it upon myself in the...
- Readers may be interested in knowing that the Lond...
- As predicted here (almost) in an earlier posting, ...
- The Israeli daily Ha'aretz is reporting that some ...
- Since this is a Beirut-based blog, I suppose it's ...
- I guess we might as well sit back and get used to ...
- The Washington Post is reporting here that U.S. in...
- Very important piece in the New Republic by Iraqi ...
- Has the U.S. been bugging the European Union's hea...
- Moving the goalposts Did you her White House spoke...
- Reason magazine has been kind enough to reprint an...
- A good reason for war Readers might be interested ...
- Dead end? My (guarded) optimism in the preliminary...
- The prisoner News that Gen. Nizar Khazraji has dis...
- Hide and go to war Did the Bush administration con...
- Interesting article in the Washington Times on the...
- Cool under fire For an unhysterical reading of U.S...
- Frisson of democracy? It was pretty easy to pick m...
- Taranto beats up a corpse The following passage is...
- Chinese diplomats are among the first to decamp fr...
- The German daily Tagzeitung has reported that an i...
- When will the shooting start? Al-Hayat is reportin...
- There were two things genuinely surreal about the ...
- The New York Times is reporting that the Bush admi...
- This from the opening paragraphs of a story from M...
- What should one make of an item published last wee...
- AP is reporting: "President Bush announced Friday ...
- Before it's too late, I have decided to read throu...
- Strange how very little has been written in the US...
- From the Will the Iraqis fight? file: Radio France...
- In Slate Mickey Kaus highlighted this article in t...
- [3/13/2003 10:31:17 PM | Michael Young] For some o...
-
▼
March
(100)
No comments:
Post a Comment