Neoconspiracy
Here is a useful, if ultimately unsatisfactory, effort (in the Chronicle of Higher Education) by Robert J. Lieber, a professor of government and foreign service at Georgetown University, to debunk the myth that the Iraq war was a conspiracy by a "small band of neoconservative (read, Jewish) defense intellectuals, led by the "mastermind," Deputy Secretary of Defense Paul Wolfowitz (according to Michael Lind, writing in the New Statesman), has taken advantage of 9/11 to put their ideas over on an ignorant, inexperienced, and "easily manipulated" president (Eric Alterman in The Nation), his "elderly figurehead" Defense Secretary (as Lind put it), and the "dutiful servant of power" who is our secretary of state (Edward Said, London Review of Books)."
The effort is useful because there has indeed been a lazy propensity to simply assume a neo-con conspiracy without actually getting bogged down in checking out the details possibly contradicting it; unsatisfactory, because (a) Lieber artificially pastes together different views of different people (as the above passage shows) in such a way that he attributes a unity of purpose when none might exist (why should Alterman be made to speak in the same voice as Said?); and (b) as in most debunking efforts, Lieber often tends to overstate his own thesis, to the extent that those aspects of the conspiracy theory which might be relevant, are instead lost in his general criticism.
FREE MINDS FOR THE MIDDLE EAST
Monday, May 05, 2003
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Blog Archive
-
▼
2003
(309)
-
▼
May
(36)
- The perils of Karim For those still interested in ...
- What they didn't notice Wolfowitz say As debate co...
- Converting Iraq? Tim Cavanaugh at Reason has put o...
- Landing Salam Pax Salam Pax exists and just to pro...
- Chalabi's patsies? Over at Slate, Jack Shafer is c...
- Narcissism at Hizbullah I have written a highly cr...
- A firing at Al-Jazeera Recently, the Iraqi Nationa...
- Qassim's rebirth Fascinating story in today's Al-H...
- Young on the poverty of Arab intellectuals Chuck's...
- Ibrahim Hamidi freed? I've just received an SMS me...
- Freund on Israeli individuation Last weekend, Mich...
- Beirut's Daily Star has failed to post Saturday co...
- [Resume] Perhaps military doctrine dictates otherw...
- [Resume] Given these various agendas, what is the ...
- Playing with Hizbullah My friend Anthony Mills has...
- Several people have told me (and I've noticed) tha...
- Robin Wright has an article in today's Los Angeles...
- The plots thicken In an earlier posting during the...
- Did Fisk rip me off? I was amused to read on Andre...
- Young on the American example There is little I ca...
- Freund on letting Arabs choose an identity Chuck ...
- Pope Petraeus Readers might find this article from...
- Khatami does Beirut Iranian president Muhammad Kha...
- As a follow up to an earlier posting a few days ag...
- Perceptive readers will notice that this link come...
- Arabists and Christians Have just finished, sever...
- Bashar concedes There has been much interest in re...
- A busy week has meant relatively few postings to B...
- Round 2: Young on saving Pan-Arabism Much of what ...
- Freund-Young Round 2: Iraq's liberal urges (Becau...
- I'm less interested in what a figure like Al Qasse...
- Powell and Syria A spot analysis of Colin Powell's...
- Neoconspiracy Here is a useful, if ultimately unsa...
- Back in business. Readers might want to waste a co...
- Garner sticks it in This from a New York Times sto...
- BC will be off the air for three days as I'll be o...
-
▼
May
(36)
No comments:
Post a Comment